AGENCY INTELLIGENCE BLOG

Two agents. Same state. Same revenue. One hated the business. One couldn’t get enough.

I told that story on stage at ITC Vegas 2026. Two agency owners, both around $2 million in revenue, both in North Carolina, both carrying a virtual employee from our staffing company. One called to give his VE back. Ten to fifteen years in the business, called it a rat race, said he couldn’t find a use for it.

A few weeks later another agent called. Same revenue, same state, same size book. She already had three virtual employees and wanted a fourth.

Here’s the short version. The difference between those two agencies wasn’t talent or technology. It was routing. One had a person whose only job was deciding where every task goes. The other didn’t. That habit decides whether AI actually helps you or just becomes another tool nobody uses.

What’s the real difference between a miserable agency and a thriving one?

I hooked those two agents up. She bought his book of business. True story, really happened.

Two months later I called her and asked what she was doing differently. She said everything that comes into her agency gets routed to one person, and that person has a strict list of every task and exactly who it goes to.

That’s it. That’s the whole difference.

She wasn’t routing by job title. She was routing by logic. Licensed people did licensed tasks. Unlicensed people did unlicensed tasks. Some of her VEs were even managing bots on the tasks that didn’t need a human at all.

I believe ninety five percent of an agency’s problems come down to a lack of routing work to the right person. It’s that simple.

 

Why doesn’t your AMS matter the way you think it does?

Your AMS is not going away. But it’s not where the work happens anymore, and you already know it.

My CTO, Mitch Gibson, studied our own agency six months ago. We have eleven people. On average, four were logging into our AMS. A few hadn’t logged in at all in two years. They were using other systems.

Here’s why. Every task that comes into an agency moves through four stages:

• Intake
• Data collection
• Execution
• Client communication

Execution and client communication look almost identical across every agency in the country. A Travelers auto change needs the same information no matter whose desk it lands on.

The part that’s actually different agency to agency is the first two: intake and data collection. Your AMS is a system of record. It’s not where the work happens.

How do you actually build the roads for AI?

Herb Kelleher ran Southwest back when it only flew a triangle between Dallas, Houston, and San Antonio. His team was arguing about who their biggest competitor was. He stopped them and said none of those are it. Our competitor is the car.

That’s exactly what’s happening in our agencies. Our biggest competitor isn’t the agency down the road. It’s the fact that we keep doing the same work the wrong way, and every time we get busy, we hire somebody instead of fixing how the work moves.

Best practice says 55 percent of your revenue should go toward your people. Most of us run 60 to 70. AI is going to drop that to 40 or less in the next two to three years. For a million dollar agency, that’s a savings of 200,000 dollars or more.

The biggest crime in our industry right now is people selling bots with no roads in your agency to drive them on. No lanes, no traffic lights, no stop signs. That’s why carriers are nervous.

You build the roads with AI that actually learns your agency. If you do your e mails every day in Outlook or Gmail, in ninety days AI should be able to do 95 percent of them for you, because it watched you do it.

Data is the rails. AI is the train.

 

What can you do about it this week?

Ask your own people who’s actually using your AMS and who isn’t. I promise you’ll be surprised, and I promise some of what they tell you won’t match what the system shows. Build something that tracks it instead of taking their word for it.

Then look at intake and data collection, the two stages that are actually different in your shop, and start standardizing those first. Fix the routing before you buy the bot.
A few questions I get asked after this talk

Is the AMS going away?

No. It’s just not where the actual work happens anymore, and most agencies are organized like it still is.

What’s the single biggest fix an agency owner can make?

Route by task logic, not job title. Build a list of every task type and exactly who or what handles it: licensed staff, unlicensed staff, a virtual employee, or a bot.

I wrote the Independent Agency Operations Manual to walk through exactly what she was doing in North Carolina. The 2025 version was downloaded over 2,700 times. This year’s is already past 1,600.
No sponsors. No pitch. Just the manual I wish somebody had handed me years ago.


The AI2030 Future-Ready Manual is free at agencyintelligence.com

Jason Cass

Jason Cass is a thought leader, speaker, agency owner and champion for the independent insurance industry. He is the founder of Agency Intelligence (AI), a place where insurance agents and agency owners can connect, share knowledge and work together to improve their agencies and move the industry forward. Jason hosts two major insurance podcast series, Agent’s Influence and Agency Intelligence where he talks with those that influence the insurance industry and connects with independent insurance agents all over the country. He is also the author of the Amazon Bestselling book, Customer Service is Just Foreplay, and is working on his second book titled, The Great Separator.

Subscribe

Pin It on Pinterest